Why Java EE 8 Adoption is Stalling in 2023

Java EE (Java Platform, Enterprise Edition) has been a staple in the enterprise application development world for many years. However, in 2023, it’s apparent that the adoption of Java EE 8 is stalling. This post will examine the factors contributing to this stagnation and explore alternatives that developers are gravitating towards.

A Brief Overview of Java EE 8

Introduced in September 2017, Java EE 8 brought several improvements aimed at enhancing support for modern web applications and microservices. Notably, it provided features that improved cloud readiness, RESTful web services, and API integrations. The framework’s aim was to ease the development process for organizations looking to build scalable, reliable, and secure applications.

// Example of a simple RESTful service in Java EE 8
@Path("/hello")
public class HelloWorld {
    
    @GET
    @Produces(MediaType.TEXT_PLAIN)
    public String hello() {
        return "Hello, World!";
    }
}

In the code snippet above, we define a basic RESTful service with Java EE 8. The @Path annotation indicates the endpoint "/hello", and the @GET annotation is used to specify that this method should handle HTTP GET requests. The @Produces annotation specifies the response content type, which, in this case, is plain text. By simplifying the development of REST APIs, Java EE 8 addressed a significant need for modern applications.

Factors Behind the Stalling Adoption

1. Emergence of Microservices and Cloud-Native Architectures

One of the most significant shifts in enterprise software development has been the movement towards microservices and cloud-native architectures.

Java EE vs. Spring Boot

Unlike Java EE, Spring Boot has gained massive traction as a preferred framework for developing microservices. It allows developers to create stand-alone applications with minimal fuss, thanks to the following essential features:

• Auto-configuration: Automatically configures beans based on included libraries.
• Embedded servers: Eliminate the need for an external server, streamlining deployment.

For example, a simple Spring Boot application can be created with minimal setup, greatly enhancing developer productivity:

@SpringBootApplication
public class Application {
    public static void main(String[] args) {
        SpringApplication.run(Application.class, args);
    }
}

In this example, @SpringBootApplication encompasses component scanning, auto-configuration, and property support, reflecting Spring Boot's philosophy of making things easier.

2. Competition from Lightweight Frameworks

Java EE 8 has faced increasing competition from lightweight frameworks like Micronaut and Quarkus, which are explicitly designed for cloud environments. Features that set these frameworks apart include:

• Faster startup times: Crucial for serverless architectures.
• Lower memory consumption: Vital for efficient resource utilization in cloud environments.

A typical Quarkus application looks like below:

@Path("/greet")
public class GreetingResource {

    @GET
    @Produces(MediaType.TEXT_PLAIN)
    public String greet() {
        return "Hello from Quarkus!";
    }
}

This snippet looks eerily similar to Java EE’s RESTful service, but Quarkus optimizes for the GraalVM, offering a much lighter footprint.

3. The Shift to Reactive Programming

As more businesses demand reactive systems capable of handling asynchronous requests, traditional Java EE has often been seen as lacking in this domain. While Java EE 8 introduced some reactive capabilities, frameworks like Vert.x and Project Reactor have outpaced it by providing robust solutions catered to the reactive paradigm.

The reactive paradigm allows for more efficient resource handling and is particularly suited for applications requiring high concurrency.

4. Industry Feedback and Market Perception

Java EE has historically been perceived as heavyweight and cumbersome, especially in contrast to the nimbleness of microservices and serverless architecture. Organizations that previously invested time and money into Java EE frameworks feel hesitant to transition to a newer version when modern alternatives promise rapid delivery and relative ease of use.

Moreover, the recent changes regarding Java EE's transition to Jakarta EE have caused confusion for some developers. Concerns over licensing, migration, and community support contribute to a fragmented community that finds it difficult to unify towards Java EE or its successor.

5. Lack of Major Updates

Lastly, the pace of updates to Java EE has been slow. This inertia can be problematic for a rapidly evolving tech landscape. New entrants dominate the conversation with agile feature releases and active communities.

In contrast, Java EE’s lengthy release cycles mean that by the time a feature is released, it might already be outdated. Developers want frameworks that continuously adapt to their needs.

What Lies Ahead?

As the adoption of Java EE 8 stalls, companies must evaluate their strategic choices for enterprise development. Here are several alternatives worth exploring:

Jakarta EE

Now that Java EE has transitioned to Jakarta EE, it offers a new path for developers who want to stay within the Jakarta ecosystem. Keep an eye on their evolving roadmaps and how they aim to address the challenges presented in the previous sections.

Spring Boot

As discussed earlier, Spring Boot remains a leading choice for many developers transitioning to microservices architecture. Its extensive ecosystem, coupled with great community support, makes it a reliable option for modern application requirements.

Quarkus

Quarkus has garnered interest as a cloud-native framework optimized for Kubernetes. Its focus on startup time, memory usage, and a simplified developer experience makes it ideal for containerized applications.

Micronaut

Micronaut is another framework rising in popularity due to its fast startup time and low memory footprint. Its ahead-of-time compilation allows for reduced allocation times and faster execution of applications.

The Bottom Line

The stagnation of Java EE 8 adoption in 2023 is a multifaceted issue rooted in the evolving demands of software development. As microservices architecture, lightweight frameworks, and reactive programming patterns continue to shape the industry, Java EE is at a crossroads.

Developers can no longer afford to remain tethered to a framework perceived as slowing them down. Instead, organizations may find that embracing new technologies — such as Jakarta EE, Spring Boot, Quarkus, or Micronaut — will better serve their ambitions.

While Java EE has proven the test of time, its evolution into Jakarta EE may represent a step forward, but only if it can adapt to the rapid changes dominating the tech landscape. Transitioning from traditional Java EE practices offers invaluable opportunities for innovation and growth in a future where agility is the name of the game.

---

For further insights on this topic, check out Jakarta EE's official site or explore what Spring Boot has to offer.